Sutcliffe had a long baseball career, playing eight years in the majors from 1884 to 1892. He was picked up by Washington in 1891, playing on the American Association team. He batted .353 in 53 games. Well liked, good natured and a fairly good hitter. He passed away in 1893 at the age of 30 from Bright’s disease. He was born and raised in Wheaton, Illinois.
“It is many years now since old “Cy” Sutcliffe appeared at the lake front and told Cap Anson he was a catcher. Uncle took him out and had them throw at him, and was much pleaded with his ready style. Said he to Sutcliffe: “You are quite a catcher. What salary would you want for playing?” Sutcliffe looked very wise “Waal, Cap.” said he, “I’ve been gittin’ a dollar a day workin’ out ter Wheaton, and I couldn’t afford ter play ball fer any less!” Poor old Sutcliffe! The grass is green over his Wheaton grave, but he caught for much more than a dollar a day, and saw much of the world beyond the little town of Wheaton before he passed away.” 1898, Chicago News.
